^ Actually, whereas I still feel that the chances of a cold SE winter went down solidly once El Nino failed and I'm not going to back down from that, I don't think that the rising chance of a weak Nina vs neutral makes those chances any lower.. If anything, they rise back to the avg for all winters. Here's why using KATL as a proxy for the SE as a whole:
Coldest 20% were: 1/7 of SEN, 1/3 of MEN to WEN, 1/8 of N, 1/5 of WLN, 1/7 of MLN, 1/14 of SLN
Clearly, one can see that MEN to WEN is the sweet spot. Once that is missed, the chance plunges from 1/3 to 1/8 when going to N. However, it actually is better to be in the WLN area vs N with 1/5 or average chance for all winters. Now, if it cooled further to MLN and especially SLN territory, chances would look worse again to have a top 20% cold winter.
Coldest 10% were: 0% of SEN, 1/4 of MEN to WEN, 1/18 of N, 1/8 of WLN, 1/16 of MLN, 0% of SLN
Similar pattern to top 20%. A WLN winter's chances of being very cold are pretty close to the chance for all winters, combined.
Summary: if we can't get a WEN/MEN, which is by far the best option, then I'd rather be at WLN than anything else for the best shot at a cold SE winter since it gives us a near average chance even though that chance is well below 50% since well under 50% of all winters are cold. All other ENSO have resulted in below average chances.
Note that I started SLN at -1.3 and MLN at -0.9 to even distribution out vs WLN