Alright so heres my thoughts on this event, especially with early on in the system with ptypes and where the snow shield sets up. I draw a lot of comparisons to the 1/5 system to this one. The 1/5 system was a much stronger wave overall and CAD was a bit stronger with that one. Still similar processes involved here. Something a lot of people maybe remember is how the NAM tried to depict the snow shield in that last system and how far north developed it leaving southern and SW VA with a little snow but mostly getting missed out on the precipitation. While the times here are not exactly the same you can see how wrong it was.
View attachment 168165View attachment 168166
While the NAM is great at sensing warm noses, its overestimation of WAA sends the precip too far north in most setups. I'm not doubting that the DC area is going to get a good snowstorm but the 10+ totals are laughable in my opinion because it sends the precip too far north for too long. Now that I have got this explanation out of the way I can talk about this system. Most modeling is not like the NAM as simple as that, and sets up the snow shield and solid banding starting south of Roanoke area.
View attachment 168167View attachment 168168
View attachment 168169
View attachment 168171
(I will note the HRRR is too far south here which is typical as it normally runs cold) Overall you can see the NAM is out to lunch with this and for the reasons I stated above it will be wrong again on where this inital front end thump sets up. I think the oddest thing about the NAMs depiction is how the 850 mb frontogensis is setup in a way that would make you think the snow shield would be further south but its not. Compared to the RGEM which in my opinion does really well at figuring out banding, (been my go to for years now in this case) its similar to the RGEM so why are they not the same???
View attachment 168172View attachment 168173
Anyways thats all I got for my analysis of this event, NAM will overestimate WAA and push the best banding north and will be wrong just like it was in the 1/5 system. Look I'm ready to eat my words here because meteorology is an extremely complicated science, but I'm confident my thoughts here will be close to what happens. I'm thinking a solid 3-5 inches in the Blacksburg and Roanoke area before a switch to sleet/frz rain. Edit here: not sure why the images are messed with the typing, my edit screen shows it in the correct way